Judge tells deadlocked jury in Etan Patz case to keep going
NEW YORK (AP) — Jurors deliberating in the 36-year-old missing-child case of Etan Patz said Tuesday they are deadlocked for the second time in 15 days, but a judge told them to keep trying.
The jury sent a midday note saying it was still stuck after deliberating since April 15 in the case against Pedro Hernandez. He admitted killing Etan, one of the first missing children ever pictured on a milk carton, but his defense says the confession is false.
“After serious, significant and thorough deliberations, we remain unable to reach a unanimous verdict,” wrote the jury, which has reviewed dozens of exhibits and even created a spreadsheet to organize the discussion. Jurors haven’t been locked in debate all that time; they’ve spent hours in the courtroom, listening again to testimony and even both sides’ closing arguments.
The defense asked Tuesday for a mistrial, arguing that the deliberations had gone on long enough.
“This is a tired jury that says it can’t reach a verdict, and we asked the judge to respect that,” defense lawyer Harvey Fishbein said outside court.
Prosecutors, meanwhile, sought an instruction telling jurors to reconsider their views. State Supreme Court Justice Maxwell Wiley instead asked jurors to keep deliberating while reminding them they weren’t required to reach a verdict.
Looking weary, the jurors filed out of court to keep talking.
Etan disappeared while walking to his school bus stop May 25, 1979. The anniversary would become National Missing Children’s Day after his case helped draw national attention to the cause of missing children.
Investigators dogged leads for decades before Hernandez — who had never before been a suspect — told authorities in 2012 that he had choked Etan after offering a soda to lure the boy to the basement of a store where he worked. Hernandez, now 54, said he had put Etan’s body in a box and walked it a few blocks away.
Etan’s body has never been found.
Long before a tip led police to Hernandez’s door in Maple Shade, New Jersey, he told some friends and relatives he’d killed a child in New York. His lawyers say all his confessions are imaginary, produced by mental illness. They also have pointed to a longtime suspect — now jailed in Pennsylvania — who was never charged.