Ex-Blackwater guard indicted on murder charge
May. 09, 2014
WASHINGTON (AP) — A former Blackwater Worldwide security guard accused of taking part in a 2007 shooting of Iraqi civilians at a Baghdad traffic circle has been indicted on a first-degree murder charge, U.S. prosecutors said Friday.
The federal grand jury indictment of Nicholas Slatten came just weeks after a judge dismissed all charges against him because of statute-of-limitation concerns.
Also Friday, the U.S. Attorney's office in Washington, D.C., asked that Slatten go on trial with the other three defendants in the incident, a move that the defense may seek to avoid. A joint trial is often viewed as an advantage for prosecutors.
In court papers, the prosecution said a joint trial is especially appropriate because the criminal conduct charged in the indictments at issue was part of a single incident. In addition, says the court filing, it would be grossly inefficient to try the case twice, inasmuch as the trial will involve 70 to 80 witnesses, many of whom live overseas. The trial is projected to last about five months.
The guards are scheduled to stand trial in Washington's federal court next month on charges arising from the Sept. 16, 2007 shootings. The contractors are accused in the deaths of 14 Iraqis and the injuries of more than a dozen others, shootings that inflamed anti-American sentiment in Iraq.
Prosecutors have portrayed Slatten as a central figure in the shootings, arguing that he fired the first shots at Nisoor Square without justification at a driver who was stopped at the traffic circle. In a statement Friday, the U.S. Attorney's office called that killing "intentional and unprovoked."
Defense attorneys for the Blackwater guards have said their clients were fired upon first, and returned fire in an act of self-defense.
Slatten's lawyer, Thomas Connolly, declined to comment Friday.
Separate trials are often favored by defendants because the separation can narrow the range of evidence that can be introduced by prosecutors, said University of Michigan law professor Samuel Gross, who specializes in criminal procedure. In addition, a defendant may want to blame another defendant for a crime and doing so in the context of a separate trial means that the other defendant is not present to respond, said Gross.
The first-degree murder charge raises a question for the other defendants, who are charged with manslaughter. They might object to going on trial with Slatten in a first-degree murder case that underscores for a jury the seriousness of the shootings. First-degree murder carries a mandatory term of life imprisonment on conviction.
Slatten faces arraignment on Monday. The grand jury indictment was handed up Thursday and was made public Friday.
U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth dismissed the indictment against Slatten on April 23 after a federal appeals court said the statute of limitations had lapsed before the government filed the charges against Slatten last October. The statute of limitations restricts the time in which legal proceedings may be brought. There is no time limit on bringing a case of first-degree murder.
Bringing a murder case raises the bar on getting a conviction because the government would have to prove that the shootings were premeditated. Slatten had been charged with manslaughter, attempted manslaughter and using a firearm in a crime of violence.
Prosecutors have said they plan to introduce evidence against Slatten unrelated to the Nisoor Square shootings.
According to a court filing by prosecutors in March, Slatten said he wanted to kill as many Iraqis as he could as "payback for 9/11," and he repeatedly boasted about the number of Iraqis he had shot, including an old Iraqi woman who had a knife in her hand. That incident occurred while Slatten was in the Army, the filing stated.
In various locations in Baghdad, the court filing said, Slatten deliberately fired his weapon to draw out return fire and instigate gun battles in a manner that was inconsistent with the use of force and escalation of force policies that governed Blackwater personnel in Iraq.