US judges weigh 4 states' gay marriage cases
AMANDA LEE MYERS
Aug. 06, 2014
CINCINNATI (AP) — A federal appeals court judge hearing arguments in a landmark hearing Wednesday on gay marriage fights in four states expressed deep skepticism about whether the courts are the ideal setting for such major change, saying that the best way to win the hearts and minds of Americans on the issue would be the democratic process.
Three judges from the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals heard arguments in six cases from Ohio, Kentucky, Michigan and Tennessee in the biggest such session on the issue so far. The cases pit states' rights and traditional, conservative values against what plaintiffs' attorneys say is a fundamental right to marry under the U.S. Constitution.
If the court decides against gay marriage, that would create a divide among federal appeals courts and put pressure on the U.S. Supreme Court to settle the issue for good in its 2015 session. The appeals panel did not indicate when it would rule.
Two federal appeals courts have already ruled in favor of gay marriage. On Tuesday, Utah appealed one of those rulings, asking the U.S. Supreme Court to take up the case and uphold its ban. Oklahoma followed suit a day later.
Since the U.S. Supreme Court struck down part of the Clinton-era federal Defense of Marriage Act last year, gay marriage advocates have won more than 20 victories in federal courts. No decision has gone the other way in that time.
On Wednesday in Cincinnati, Judge Jeffrey S. Sutton peppered attorneys with the question and said it was strange that the same-sex couples fighting statewide bans weren't showing more patience.
"I would have thought the best way to get respect and dignity is through the democratic process," Sutton said. "Nothing happens as quickly as we'd like it. ... I'm not 100 percent sure it's the better route for the gay rights community."
Another judge on the panel criticized Sutton's argument Wednesday, saying that sometimes courts need to intervene when constitutional rights are being violated.
Judge Martha Craig Daughtrey, a Bill Clinton nominee, pointed out that it took decades for women to win the right to vote.
"Do you have any knowledge of how many years I'm talking about, going into every state, every city, every state board of elections, for 70 years?" Daughtrey said of women's efforts to get the vote. "It didn't work. It took an amendment to the Constitution."
Sutton, a George W. Bush nominee, is known for being unpredictable, shocking Republicans in 2011 when he became the deciding vote in a 6th Circuit ruling that upheld President Barack Obama's health care law.
The afternoon of arguments opened with Michigan's solicitor general, Aaron Lindstrom, saying that any change in the state's ban on same-sex marriage should come through the political process.
Fundamental constitutional rights shouldn't be decided in popular votes, countered attorney Carole Stanyar, who represents the plaintiffs in that case.
In Ohio's cases, Cincinnati civil rights attorney Al Gerhardstein said the state's refusal to recognize out-of-state gay marriages violates the dignity of same-sex couples and amounts to unique discrimination, since Ohio has historically recognized marriages in other states that wouldn't be legal in Ohio, such as between cousins or involving minors.
Eric Murphy, Ohio's state solicitor, said Ohio has traditionally defined marriage as between a man and a woman and that same-sex marriage is too new to be considered a deeply rooted, fundamental right.
Outside the courthouse in nearby Fountain Square, advocates held up banners and signs urging freedom to marry. About a dozen gay marriage opponents prayed the rosary outside the courthouse.
The 6th Circuit is the first of three federal appeals courts to hear arguments from multiple states in coming weeks. The 7th Circuit in Chicago has similar arguments set for Aug. 26 for bans in Wisconsin and Indiana. The 9th Circuit in San Francisco is set to take up Idaho's and Nevada's bans Sept. 8.
Gay marriage is legal in 19 states and the Washington capital district.
Associated Press writers Lisa Cornwell and Dan Sewell contributed. Follow Amanda Lee Myers on Twitter at https://twitter.com/AmandaLeeAP